Markit Recap – 8/11/2014

https://theleadleft.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/cropped-THE-LEAD-ICON.png
Content hub / Article / Markit Recap – 8/11/2014

We remarked last week that Banco Espirito Santo’s travails may test current CDS definitions, and so they did.

But not in the way that we – or most market participants – expected. The Portuguese lender was split into a “good” bank – a new entity called Novo Banca – and the existing Banco Espirito Santo. The higher quality assets will reside at Novo Banca, with deposits and senior debts on the liability side of the balance sheet. Banco Espirito Santo will be left with the “toxic” assets, as well as the equity and subordinated bonds. BES will be wound down over a period of years.

 

This is effectively a bail-in of subordinated bondholders, but not in the explicit manner that was predicted by the markets and caused sub CDS spreads to widen well beyond 1,000bps on August 1. Government involvement and a consequent restructuring credit event seemed the most likely scenario, and the case of SNS Bank in 2013 showed that state intervention can pose significant problems for CDS triggering mechanisms.

However, the BES restructuring has shown that government action can expose flaws in CDS succession events, as well as credit events. ISDA ruled on August 8 that a succession event had taken place on BES, meaning that all the CDS will be transferred to Novo Banca. In the case of a financial entity, this entails both senior and subordinated CDS. This means that the latter will be “orphaned“ – there will be no deliverables on Novo Banca sub CDS as all the sub bonds will remain obligations of banco Espirito Santo.

The market reaction? BES subordinated CDS tightened from 1161bps on the Friday preceding the weekend announcement to 500bps when the succession event was confirmed. Senior CDS rallied from 674bps to 350bps over the same period, a reflection of Novo Banca’s stronger balance sheet and the reduced probability of a credit event (remember that a restructuring credit event on subordinated debt also triggers senior CDS under current ISDA definitions).

How would this have played out if the ISDA 2014 definitions had already been implemented? Succession rules for financials would have been different, with amendments to take into account the possibility of a good bank-bad bank split. The example of Spanish institution Bankia had already showed that the current definitions failed to take this type of restructuring into account. Under 2014 rules, subordinated CDS will track the subordinated debt, so the orphaning of BES sub CDS holders probably wouldn’t have happened. This is a common sense approach and seems obvious, but bank splits weren’t everyday occurrences back in 2003, when the current ISDA definitions were drafted.

We have seen several bank restructurings forced by governments in recent years, and it will be no surprise to see more bail-ins in a climate when the official sector and taxpayers have been scarred by the costs of rescuing financial institutions. From the beginning of 2016, an EU directive forcing bail-in of bondholders – both subordinated and senior – will come into effect, and governments will have far less discretion in sharing the burden of bank rescues.

 

Contact: Gavan Nolan 

Gavan.Nolan@markit.com

Making sense of private credit defaults

Webinar

Making sense of private credit defaults

What does private credit default data really tell us? Join our exclusive webinar featuring experts from KBRA, Moody's, Fitch Ratings, and S&P Global to find out.
Register
Credit Journal-Private Credit

Report

Credit Journal-Private Credit

Fitch Ratings’ latest Credit Journal series is a subject-specific, curated compilation of in-depth research and commentary. This edition explores the growing world of private credit, including non-bank lending across business development companies.
Download
PitchBook's US PE Middle Market Report

Report

PitchBook's US PE Middle Market Report

The middle market is off to its best start to a year since 2021, but its share of PE keeps slipping.
Download
Private Debt Investor New York Forum

September 15-16, Hudson Yards, New York

Private Debt Investor New York Forum

Bringing together the investors, managers and advisers shaping the next phase of the market — 200+ allocators and $10.6 trillion of LP capital expected. Benchmark strategies, hear from leading LPs, and cut through market noise over two unmissable days.
Learn more

Latest news

    Q2 European direct lending activity up 9%

    Despite the geopolitical and macroeconomic events of the first half of the year creating a volatile environment, the European private credit market continues to demonstrate robust resilience.

    Read More

    Share of PE middle-market fund count by size bucket

    Sector composition tilted hard toward B2B in Q1. B2B accounted for 52.9% of middle-market exit value, up from 38.2% in full-year 2025…

    Read More

    The Lead Left rebrands as The Lead, expanding into a multi-format platform for private capital intelligence

    New York, July 16, 2026 – The Lead Left, the private capital thought leadership platform founded by Randy Schwimmer in 2008, today announced its rebrand as The Lead…

    Read More